Thursday, January 12, 2006

My Open Question to Judge Samuel Alito

The one question I would like Alito to answer -- after watching him dance around the issue of the limits of Presidential power for two days -- is this:

Given the current claims of the Bush administration that the President can, in a time of war, pretty much do whatever he wants--regardless of law--my question is this:

What, if anything, in the Constitution or in any existing law, prevents a president from becoming a dictator?

In other words, what in our existing law or constitution prevents ANY president from using this kind of rationale to bestow upon himself UNLIMITED powers over the government and the people of the United States. It seems all he has to do is create a permanent and ongoing war, and by virtue of Bush's current reasoning, what he says--should HE and he alone deem it necessary for "national security"-- goes--no checks, no balances.

Further, if this is permitted, is not our system of government effectively changed from a democracy to a dictatorship? If not, why not?

2 comments:

Unknown said...

Right on, TUC. This is perhaps the question as it gets to the heart of the most critical matter facing the US. Will it continue down the road of fascism, corporatism or whatever other "ism" we want to call a dictatorship fueled by corporate interests? Or, will we change course and begin the crucial journey of transforming, fundamentally, our ostensible democracy into the real thing?

The latter question takes us far beyond the Alito issue; however, the situation will be made infinitely more dire if Alito is confirmed.

Have you passed along your question to anyone on the Senate Judiciary Committee who can ask this question of Alito? Telephone/email/fax them ASAP.

Keep up the great work, dear friend.

Sean (iNoodle.com)

The Unknown Candidate said...

Thanks so much, Sean. Yes, indeed...I have passed it on to Kennedy ... along with my earlier posting of Scott Turow's question... but so far... haven't heard either question posed. I will follow up with Kennedy's office and others on the committee. (I more than welcome any and all to do the same....)

Thanks once again for your support, Sean. As always, it is much appreciated. As is your great work on inoodle.com.